Short answer: build it entirely from what your household and garden already produce. Kitchen scraps, garden trimmings, lawn clippings, fallen leaves, cardboard, and manure if you keep animals -- balanced roughly between nitrogen-rich "green" material and carbon-rich "brown" material, kept appropriately moist, and turned occasionally for air. No bought activator, bin or bagged fertiliser is actually required. Compost is the one source of soil fertility that costs nothing and never runs out, because the inputs are things you already have.
Last updated 5 November 2026
On This Page
All 18 Resilience Gardening guides in one printable 121-page PDF. See what's inside
Compost Is Free Fertility, Not a Product to Buy
Garden centres sell compost activators, tumbling bins, and bagged fertiliser, and all of it can be genuinely useful -- but none of it is required. Compost happens because of biology, not brand names: carbon-rich and nitrogen-rich material broken down by microorganisms, with moisture and oxygen keeping the process running. A heap built from kitchen scraps, garden waste, fallen leaves and cardboard, in a roughly 50/50 mix of green and brown material, will compost perfectly well in a simple pile or a homemade enclosure of pallets or chicken wire.
Getting the balance right matters more than any bought input. Too much green material (fresh, wet, nitrogen-rich) and a heap turns slimy, compacted and smelly. Too much brown material (dry, carbon-rich) and it breaks down agonisingly slowly. The practical fix is simple: alternate layers, or mix as you add material, aiming for roughly equal parts by volume rather than by weight, since brown material is usually much lighter.
One thing that genuinely does change the details is climate. The core biology is identical everywhere, but a heap in a cool, wet maritime climate needs protection from excess rain and some insulation to keep working through winter, while the same heap in an arid climate needs the opposite -- deliberate moisture management to stop it drying out and stalling completely. This site's dedicated compost section covers a full method built specifically for each of the 8 climate zones, rather than one generic guide stretched to fit everywhere.
What to Leave Out
- Meat, fish and dairy, which attract rats and flies and can smell. They can be composted in a hot, enclosed system, but not in a simple open heap.
- Cat and dog droppings, which can carry parasites and diseases harmful to people.
- Diseased plants, such as potatoes with blight, unless your heap gets properly hot.
- Perennial weed roots and seeding weeds, such as bindweed, couch grass and docks, which survive a cool heap. Drown them in a bucket of water for a few weeks first, or use a hot heap.
- Glossy or coloured paper, treated wood, and coal or charcoal ash, which can contain unwelcome chemicals.
- Large amounts of citrus, onion or cooked food, which rot slowly or attract pests.
Hot or Cold Composting
| Hot composting | Cold composting | |
|---|---|---|
| How it works | A big heap, at least about a cubic metre, built all at once and turned often. It heats to around 55 to 65 °C. | You add material as it comes, and let it rot slowly with little or no turning. |
| Time to finish | About 1 to 3 months | About 6 to 12 months or more |
| Kills weed seeds and disease? | Largely, when the heat is held | Not reliably |
| Effort | More, because you need enough material and need to turn it | Very little |
| Best for | Large amounts of material, weeds and speed | A small garden and a relaxed approach |
Most home gardeners do a mix: fill one bay over time and let it rot, then start a second. Both give good compost.
Where to Find Free Materials
If your own garden does not produce enough, there is often plenty to be had for free:
- Leaves. Autumn leaves from streets, parks and neighbours are one of the best free carbon sources. Make leaf mould, or add them to the heap.
- Cardboard. Shops and households throw it out in huge amounts. Remove tape and labels.
- Grass clippings and prunings. Neighbours with lawns often welcome help clearing them, but avoid lawns treated with weedkiller.
- Manure and bedding. Horse owners, stables and farms may give away manure and straw. Let it age before use.
- Coffee grounds and kitchen waste. Cafés and neighbours sometimes keep them for gardeners.
- Seaweed. Gathered in small quantities from the strandline, where permitted, it is a great addition.
- Wood chip. Tree surgeons often have loads to dispose of. It suits paths and mulch more than the heap.
Check that anything you collect is free of herbicide residues, particularly manure and hay, because some weedkillers survive composting and can damage crops.
Knowing When It Is Ready, and Using It
- Ready compost is dark, crumbly and earthy-smelling, and you can no longer recognise what went into it. A few twigs and eggshell pieces are fine; put them back in the next heap.
- Top dressing. Spread 5 to 10 centimetres on beds, either in autumn or before planting. See building healthy soil without fertiliser.
- Planting. Mix a handful into planting holes for hungry crops such as squash and brassicas.
- Seed compost. Sieve well-rotted compost, ideally mixed with sand or leaf mould, for seedlings.
As a guide, a heap shrinks to roughly a third of its original volume as it rots, so you need a lot of raw material to make a little compost. That is why collecting extra from outside the garden is worthwhile.
Other Free Fertility Alongside Compost
- Leaf mould. Leaves piled in a wire cage for a year or two make a wonderful soil conditioner.
- Comfrey and nettle feed. Steep the leaves in water for a few weeks for a nutrient-rich liquid, diluted before use. It smells strong.
- Green manures. Sown and dug in, they add organic matter and, for legumes, nitrogen.
- Mulch. Straw, grass and leaves laid on the soil feed it as they rot, and cut watering.
- Worm composting. A worm bin turns kitchen scraps into rich compost in a small space, even for a flat.
Common Mistakes
- Too much green and not enough brown. The usual cause of smell and slime.
- Letting it dry out. A dry heap does nothing.
- Adding meat, dairy or cat and dog waste. It attracts pests and may carry disease.
- Using composted manure or hay with herbicide residues. It can damage crops.
- Making the heap too small. A bigger heap holds heat and breaks down faster.
- Giving up too soon. Cold compost takes months, and that is fine.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I make compost without buying anything?
By building a heap entirely from what a household and garden already produce -- kitchen scraps, garden trimmings, lawn clippings, fallen leaves, cardboard and paper, and manure if any animals are kept -- balanced roughly between nitrogen-rich "green" material and carbon-rich "brown" material, kept appropriately moist, and turned occasionally to keep it aerated. No bought activator, bin or fertiliser is actually required for compost to work.
What's the difference between green and brown compost material?
Green material is nitrogen-rich and usually fresh and moist -- kitchen scraps, grass clippings, fresh garden waste -- while brown material is carbon-rich and usually dry -- fallen leaves, cardboard, straw, woody prunings. A heap needs a reasonable balance of both; too much green turns slimy and smelly, too much brown breaks down painfully slowly.
Does compost-making change depending on climate zone?
Yes, genuinely -- the core biology (carbon, nitrogen, moisture, oxygen) is the same everywhere, but what that means in practice changes a lot by climate: a heap in a cool, wet climate needs protection from excess rain and insulation to keep working, while the same heap in an arid climate needs the opposite, active moisture management to stop it drying out and stalling.
What is the right ratio of greens to browns?
Somewhere between equal parts and about two parts brown to one part green, by volume. Add more brown if it is wet and smelly, and more green if it is dry and slow.
How long does compost take to make?
A hot, turned heap can be ready in one to three months. A cold, unturned heap usually takes six to twelve months or longer.
Can I compost cooked food, meat or dairy?
Not in a simple open heap, because they attract rats and flies. They can be composted in a hot, enclosed system, but it is simplest to leave them out.
Do I need a compost bin?
No. A pile, a pallet bay or a wire mesh cylinder all work. A bin helps by keeping it tidy and holding in heat and moisture.
Why does my compost smell?
Usually too many wet greens and not enough air. Mix in dry browns such as shredded cardboard or straw, and turn the heap.
Can I compost weeds?
Weeds that have not set seed can go in. Perennial roots and seeding weeds should be drowned in water first, or only added to a properly hot heap.
Where can I get free compost materials?
Autumn leaves, cardboard, neighbours' grass clippings, manure and bedding from stables or farms, coffee grounds, seaweed and tree-surgeon wood chip are all often free.
How much compost can I make from a heap?
A heap shrinks to roughly a third of its starting volume as it rots, so a cubic metre of raw material makes about a third of a cubic metre of compost.